SEO Heist

What are real-world examples of SEO Heist cases?

The best-known real-world SEO heist came from a viral late-2023 post on X, in which marketer Jake Ward described how a site exported a competitor’s sitemap, turned the URLs into titles and generated AI articles for each. The thread drew heavy criticism, and later reporting showed the copying site’s traffic dropping sharply. It became the reference case for the term.

The 2023 case

  • What happened: the copying site, identified in press coverage as Causal, a finance software company, published AI articles mirroring topics from Exceljet, a site run by an Excel educator.
  • Reaction: SEOs and the competitor’s founder criticized it publicly as copying, and the story spread beyond marketing circles.
  • Aftermath: third-party traffic estimates reported a steep decline for the copying site. Google does not comment on individual cases, so the exact mechanism is not public.

For how the tactic works and the legitimate alternative, see what an SEO heist is.

The policy response

A few months later Google published its March 2024 core update and spam policies post, adding scaled content abuse, expired domain abuse and site reputation abuse to its spam policies. Scaled content abuse covers many pages “generated for the primary purpose of manipulating Search rankings and not helping users,” which describes the heist method closely. Many sites relying on mass-produced content lost visibility during that rollout.

Lessons

LessonTakeaway
Public tactics get scrutinizedBragging about copying invites reports and press
Short-term traffic is fragileVolume without value rarely survives updates
The victim had the stronger assetOriginal expertise outlasted the copies

What a durable competitor strategy looks like

The case shows demand for competitor topics is real; the method was the problem. The durable version targets competitor-intent searches with original work: alternatives pages that recommend the right tool for each use case, sourced “X vs Y” comparisons, migration guides and integration pages. These are also the pages AI engines tend to cite for “alternatives to X” prompts. Our programmatic SEO post-mortem is a candid look at why scale without value fails.

Frequently asked questions

Who coined the term SEO heist?

It was popularized by a late-2023 post on X from marketer Jake Ward, who described the tactic as an SEO heist. Press coverage identified the sites involved as Causal and its competitor Exceljet.

Did the heist site get penalized?

Public traffic estimates reported after the backlash showed a steep decline for the copying site. Google does not comment on individual sites, so the exact cause is not confirmed.

Are there other SEO heist examples?

Many sites were hit when Google rolled out its March 2024 core update and spam policies, which targeted scaled low-value content, but most were not publicly identified as copying a specific competitor.

Do not let AI keep
recommending someone else

Start your 7-day free trial and get your AI Visibility Score in about a minute. See exactly where you stand, where competitors are beating you, and the ranked fixes to get into the answer. Cancel anytime before the trial ends.

7-day free trial. Cancel anytime before it ends. Trusted by 500+ B2B SaaS teams.

Partnered with
Powered by