SEO Heist

Can hiring an unethical SEO agency lead to an SEO Heist?

Yes. An unethical agency can run an SEO heist for you by exporting a competitor’s sitemap and publishing mass-produced AI pages on your domain. Google applies its spam policies, including scaled content abuse, to the site, so you carry the risk of demotion or a manual action, plus any copyright complaints from the competitor.

Red flags when hiring

Red flagWhy it matters
Pricing per page publishedRewards volume over usefulness
“We’ll take your competitor’s traffic” pitchOften means cloning their content
Guaranteed rankingsNo one can guarantee Google results
No subject-matter expert reviewPoints to bulk AI output
Won’t share URLs or drafts before publishingHides what goes on your domain

Ask directly how they use AI. Google’s guidance on AI content says automation is fine when the content is helpful, and spam when it is used mainly to manipulate rankings. A good agency can explain where AI fits and where humans add expertise.

If an agency already did it

  1. Audit recent publishing for pages that mirror a competitor’s URLs or text.
  2. Remove or rewrite pages with no original value.
  3. Check Search Console’s Manual actions report and file a reconsideration request if needed.
  4. Put publishing approval in your contract.

What to ask an agency for instead

If you want a competitor’s audience, brief the agency on a legitimate competitor program:

  • Gap analysis first: a list of competitor-intent queries mapped to buyer stages.
  • A small set of high-value pages: alternatives, “X vs Y” comparisons, switching guides and integration pages.
  • Sourcing rules: every competitor fact linked to a public source and dated.
  • Trademark care: competitor names used only to identify products, no implied endorsement.
  • Reporting on outcomes: rankings for competitor queries, demo requests, and inclusion in AI answers to “alternatives to X” prompts.

Our post on owning competitor alternative searches is a useful brief to share. For the full playbook, see what an SEO heist is.

Frequently asked questions

Am I responsible if my agency used spam tactics?

For Google, yes in practice. Penalties apply to the site, regardless of who published the pages. Any copyright complaints also target content on your domain.

How do I check what my agency has published?

Review your CMS publishing history, Search Console's Pages report for sudden jumps in indexed URLs, and sample new pages for originality and accuracy.

What should a good agency deliver for competitor keywords?

A short list of high-intent competitor pages, a sourcing method for every claim, an expert review step and a refresh schedule.

Do not let AI keep
recommending someone else

Start your 7-day free trial and get your AI Visibility Score in about a minute. See exactly where you stand, where competitors are beating you, and the ranked fixes to get into the answer. Cancel anytime before the trial ends.

7-day free trial. Cancel anytime before it ends. Trusted by 500+ B2B SaaS teams.

Partnered with
Powered by